never use valueFormatters for ticks

diff --git a/auto_tests/tests/axis_labels.js b/auto_tests/tests/axis_labels.js
index c8b3bab..fedf22b 100644 (file)
--- a/auto_tests/tests/axis_labels.js
+++ b/auto_tests/tests/axis_labels.js
@@ -192,10 +192,10 @@ AxisLabelsTestCase.prototype.testDateAxisLabelFormatter = function () {
   var opts = {
     width: 480,
     height: 320,
-    xAxisLabelFormatter: function(x, granularity) {
+    xAxisLabelFormatter: function(x, granularity, b) {
       return 'x' + x.strftime('%Y/%m/%d');
     },
-    yAxisLabelFormatter: function(y) {
+    yAxisLabelFormatter: function(y, a, b) {
       return 'y' + y;
     },
     labels: ['x', 'y']
@@ -236,14 +236,12 @@ AxisLabelsTestCase.prototype.testValueFormatter = function () {
   var graph = document.getElementById("graph");
   var g = new Dygraph(graph, data, opts);
 
-  assertEquals(["0","2","4","6","8"], getXLabels());
-
-  // This would be more consistent with the behavior of yValueFormatter:
-  // assertEquals(['x0','x2','x4','x6','x8'], getXLabels());
-
-  assertEquals(['y0','y2','y4','y6','y8','y10','y12','y14','y16','y18'], getYLabels());
+  // the valueFormatter options do not affect the ticks.
+  assertEquals(['0','2','4','6','8'], getXLabels());
+  assertEquals(['0','2','4','6','8','10','12','14','16','18'],
+               getYLabels());
 
-  // the valueFormatter options also affect the legend.
+  // they do affect the legend, however.
   g.setSelection(2);
   assertEquals("x2: y:y4", getLegend());
 };
@@ -268,16 +266,13 @@ AxisLabelsTestCase.prototype.testDateValueFormatter = function () {
   var graph = document.getElementById("graph");
   var g = new Dygraph(graph, data, opts);
 
-  // This is the existing behavior:
-  assertEquals(["01Jan","02Jan","03Jan","04Jan","05Jan","06Jan","07Jan","08Jan","09Jan"], getXLabels());
-
-  // This would be more consistent with the yValueFormatter behavior:
-  // assertEquals(["x2011/01/01", "x2011/01/02", "x2011/01/03", "x2011/01/04", "x2011/01/05", "x2011/01/06", "x2011/01/07", "x2011/01/08", "x2011/01/09"], getXLabels());
-  assertEquals(['y2','y4','y6','y8','y10','y12','y14','y16','y18'], getYLabels());
+  // valueFormatters do not affect ticks.
+  assertEquals(['01Jan','02Jan','03Jan','04Jan','05Jan','06Jan','07Jan','08Jan','09Jan'], getXLabels());
+  assertEquals(['2','4','6','8','10','12','14','16','18'], getYLabels());
 
   // the valueFormatter options also affect the legend.
   g.setSelection(2);
-  assertEquals("x2011/01/03: y:y6", getLegend());
+  assertEquals('x2011/01/03: y:y6', getLegend());
 };
 
 // This test verifies that when both a valueFormatter and an axisLabelFormatter

diff --git a/dygraph-tickers.js b/dygraph-tickers.js
index 4073076..a0c8187 100644 (file)
--- a/dygraph-tickers.js
+++ b/dygraph-tickers.js
@@ -158,7 +158,7 @@ Dygraph.numericTicks = function(a, b, pixels, opts, dygraph, vals) {
     k_labels = [ "k", "M", "G", "T" ];
   }
 
-  var formatter = opts('axisLabelFormatter') || opts('valueFormatter');
+  var formatter = opts('axisLabelFormatter');
 
   // Add labels to the ticks.
   for (var i = 0; i < ticks.length; i++) {

diff --git a/dygraph.js b/dygraph.js
index 48b48f1..dd857d6 100644 (file)
--- a/dygraph.js
+++ b/dygraph.js
@@ -243,11 +243,13 @@ Dygraph.DEFAULT_ATTRS = {
     y: {
       pixelsPerLabel: 30,
       valueFormatter: Dygraph.numberFormatter,
+      axisLabelFormatter: Dygraph.numberFormatter,
       ticker: null  // will be set in dygraph-tickers.js
     },
     y2: {
       pixelsPerLabel: 30,
       valueFormatter: Dygraph.numberFormatter,
+      axisLabelFormatter: Dygraph.numberFormatter,
       ticker: null  // will be set in dygraph-tickers.js
     }
   }